In the May 2007 issue of TGO Chris Townsend recommends clothing for 3 season backpacking. I thought I'd see how FurTech compares, even though our garments are designed for Scrambling and Mountaineering (helmet hood, pit zips, snow seal etc).
The TGO article shows each end of the ultra-light to lightweight spectrum of garments and Chris's balanced choice. A simplified version of the table is shown below, with the addition of a FurTech comparison:
|
Ultra-Light |
Light |
Chris’s Choice |
FurTech |
Baselayer |
90 |
260 |
260 |
140 |
Mid Layer |
225 |
305 |
225 |
Integral to FurTech |
Insulation |
212 |
340 |
212 |
250 |
Windproof |
71 |
292 |
166 |
110 |
Waterproof |
220 |
377 |
278 |
730 |
Walking Trs. |
334 |
463 |
463 |
610 |
Over Trs. |
110 |
298 |
110 |
Not needed |
Underpants |
27 |
51 |
27 |
27 |
|
|
|
|
|
Total |
1289 |
2386 |
1741 |
1887 |
Carried |
838 |
1612 |
991 |
1430 |
Weights in grams
Carried weight is all except baselayers and trousers (or FurTech shorts)
The FurTech Talon at 730g (actually my small size is 665g) includes integral mid layer insulation, pit zips and helmet compatible hood. The FurTech 4 Season trousers also have integrated insulation but can be converted into shorts. Insulating the large surface area of the legs adds significantly to the overall warmth of the system... counterbalanced by the vents.
At 110g the Go-Lite C-Thru shirt is an appropriate base layer, though I often use a Go-Lite T-shirt.
If I am trying to reduce weight for Alpine mountaineering I generally ditch the windproof but at 110g the Golite Ether (with hood) can be useful to keep midges at bay and to use as an alternative baselayer when the C-thru is being washed. Two baselayers may offer more options (insulation, short sleeves) if, like me, you are happy using the FurTech Talon in breezy conditions... or just save 110g.
Chris selected a Mont Bell down jacket for extra insulation. I've entered 250g for the very different (maybe inappropriate) Blizzard Vest, used for emergencies. The weights aren't dissimilar, so you take your choice.
I've kept the same weight as Chris for the underpants.
This little exercise just goes to show how lightweight feather and fur garments are, but that's not the whole story: you will be far more comfortable in the FurTech system in prolonged wet, cold or changeable conditions. Use a thicker base layer or two, lose the windproof, and this system is suitable for full on winter conditions with better breathability and durability at little extra weight... though you may want to add thicker OverShell insulation.
The downside of the FurTech option is that in warm, midge infested conditions, your legs may be a little warm when they are zipped into the trousers. If conditions are midge free, then take the legs off and you'll be cooler than the TGO options.